Would You Trade Matusz and Tillman or Arietta for Cahill?

[Old#5fan]

I think I would. This kid is young and has nasty stuff. Other than Strasburg he is the most impressive pitcher I have seen at such a young age. Now this is what a young potential "ace" looks like. We don't have anyone that good in our organization. Sorry.

[Sanfran327]

July Fools!!

[Camden_yardbird]

I think I would. This kid is young and has nasty stuff. Other than Strasburg he is the most impressive pitcher I have seen at such a young age.

No. He's good but...You're crazy. That is all.

[Hank Scorpio]

Do you post this kind of stuff just to see how many responses you get?

[Old#5fan]

No. He's good but...You're crazy. That is all.

I sure think he would look great at the top of our rotation for years to come.

[Sports Guy]

I wouldn't trade Matusz for him but I would rather have him than Tillman and Arrieta.

I would rather have Brett Anderson and Cahill vs Matusz and one of those 2 though.

[Old#5fan]

Of course. Asking about Tillman for Cahill is laughable.

You mis-read. The deal would be Matusz and one of either Tillman or Arietta. I am not that dumb to espouse a one for one of any Orioles pitcher. We have none nearly as talented as Cahill.

[Crazysilver03]

I sure think he would look great at the top of our rotation for years to come.

He would, but the 2nd and 3rd spots would belong to Bergesen and Berken. :rolleyestf:

[Sports Guy]

I sure think he would look great at the top of our rotation for years to come.

Other than tonight, how many times have you seen him pitch?

What can you tell us about him?

[Austin]

You mis-read. The deal would be Matusz and one of either Tillman or Arietta. I am not that dumb to espouse a one for one of any Orioles pitcher. We have none nearly as talented as Cahill.

No way no how. I wouldn't trade Matusz for him straight up.

[RyanW]

Why? 2 prospects and potential TOR starters for 1?

[Crazysilver03]

You mis-read. The deal would be Matusz and one of either Tillman or Arietta. I am not that dumb to espouse a one for one of any Orioles pitcher. We have none nearly as talented as Cahill.

Then you clearly dont understand talent.

[Old#5fan]

I wouldn't trade Matusz for him but I would rather have him than Tillman and Arrieta.

I would rather have Brett Anderson and Cahill vs Matusz and one of those 2 though.

He's a lot better than Matusz. Have you actually watched him? He may possibly make the All-Star team and is what 21?

[Old#5fan]

No way no how. I wouldn't trade Matusz for him straight up.

Wow, a 21 year old possible All-Star for a guy who has lost what? Nine in a row?

Oakland wouldn't do it either but the might for Matusz and Arietta or Matusz and Tillman. Either one I would do in a minute.

[Sports Guy]

He's a lot better than Matusz. Have you actually watched him? He may possibly make the All-Star team and is what 21?

I have seen him pitch multiple times...besides tonight, how many times have you seen him?